Skip to content now.

We Can Haz Equal Pay

Jan 24, 2010 / Workforce / Trackback

My Repost from Lip­stick Dis­cus­sions Dis­par­ity of Influ­ence with Mau­reen Sharib on ere community

The Glass Ceil­ing Act was was enacted with only minor changes as Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1991. Four years later in 1995 a 257 page report was pro­duced, the result of a 21 per­son panel (76% female).

The sta­tis­tics reported at that time showed that equal­ity in Cor­po­rate Amer­ica was a mess and the prog­no­sis in the report pre­dicted lit­tle if any improve­ment in the near future. The research found rel­a­tively few women and minori­ties in the pipeline posi­tions most likely to lead to the top. There was lit­tle hope for women and minori­ties in crit­i­cal career paths for senior man­age­ment posi­tions which require tak­ing on respon­si­bil­i­ties most directly related to the cor­po­rate bot­tom line.

To this day, the few women and minori­ties found at the high­est lev­els tend to be in staff posi­tions, such as human resources, or research, or admin­is­tra­tion, rather than line posi­tions, such as mar­ket­ing, sales, or production.

If you sense deja vú it could be because this topic mir­rors recent pop­u­lar dis­cus­sion ask­ing the questions

  • Is HR dead?
  • How can we increase our value proposition?
  • How can we get a seat at the table?
  • How can we be taken more seri­ously and be seen more importantly?

Look at those ques­tions and change the word­ing around a lit­tle bit. Per­son­ally, I see a lot of paralells.

So, it irri­tates me when I hear moan­ing like

If I hear the cliché seat at the table one more time I’m gonna puke.

What if I just want to be average?

I want to puke. Because we gave up. It’s our own fault. We shouldn’t have to over com­pen­sate, over­come stereo­types, work for less or work harder to get the same.

But the fact is… oh yes we do. It isn’t going to fall unto us like manna from the sky. The gov­ern­ment passed ammend­ments and acts and we still don’t have it. It’s not even easy to fix like other dif­fi­cult to achieve mile­stones that just required a vote. Face it, Women’s Suf­frage was a 70 year struggle.

I also know that boys are taught through tough love and con­tact sports to be aggres­sive  and com­pet­i­tive from a young age and girls are taught to “play nice” with dolls and stuffed ani­mals — it’s all train­ing for pri­mary rolls in life. And when it doesn’t turn out like our soci­etal con­di­tion­ing has man­dated for­ever, that girls should be sub­mis­sive and boys dom­i­nant –girls are bitches and boys are sissies.

I’m not a mother but if I had a child I would be read­ing her bed­time sto­ries in another lan­guage, word prob­lems, mak­ing games out of mem­o­riz­ing all the bones in the body. She would study mar­tial arts and I wouldn’t be read­ing her fairy tales about being saved by knights in shin­ing armor.

Why mask real­ity and then be sur­prised at the outcome?

We’re always talk­ing about best prac­tices but we have a really small lens we look through when we look at the map. We won’t take into con­sid­er­a­tion mod­els of flex­i­bil­ity, extended mater­nal leaves for births, day­cares in work­places, real vaca­tion time and time to take it from coun­tries where it works any less than we’ll accept the truth that it is noth­ing short of a crime for the rich­est coun­try on earth to have home­less peo­ple liv­ing on the streets and an infant mor­tal­ity rate that’s inexcuseable.

There’s a lot of Stock­holm Syn­drome going on, we need to wake up and I’m just get­ting warmed up…



  • http://www.whatwoulddadsay.com/ GL HOFFMAN

    Karla—good post. To me it all comes back to one word: respect. If busi­ness lead­ers really under­stood that one sim­ple word and how EVERYTHING they do, say or agree to either grows it or dimin­ishes it. Equal pay for equal work or I should say unequal pay for equal work is a sign of a dis­re­spect­ful workplace.

    • http://karlaporter.com/ Karla Porter

      GL — You sure summed it up. If only we ran the world =)

  • http://karlaporter.com/ Karla Porter

    Dan, please don’t be ner­vous. This isn’t a place for male bash­ing it is for com­mu­nity and respect­ful dia­log, I’m glad you decided to be a part of it. Your ques­tion is espe­cially inter­est­ing to me. You come with a per­spec­tive I am lit­tle famil­iar with. I have no idea if there is a gen­der based dis­par­ity in pay in Aus­tralia. How­ever, there is here. Women earn about 77 cents to the US dol­lar. It is a huge issue and one women (and minori­ties) can’t seem to shake. Of course there are women who do earn as much as their male coun­ter­parts but that’s not the norm.

    Your state­ment is bril­liant… “I can’t under­stand how/why peo­ple with same skills and expe­ri­ence would get paid differently”.

    Me either…

    And I’ve also never seen a pol­icy man­dat­ing a sep­a­rate pay rate.

    We have a lot in com­mon. Thanks so much for stop­ping by, come back again soon =)

  • dan­nuroo

    Always an inter­est­ing topic. I feel ner­vous (OK scared) typ­ing here. Can I ask one ques­tion though? Who is the war against? Who is deny­ing the “seat at the table?” Men? or all soci­ety? I’m not stir­ring the pot, I just need to understand

    I can’t under­stand how/why peo­ple with same skills and expe­ri­ence would get paid dif­fer­ently, maybe I’m just nieve? But I’ve also never seen a pol­icy man­dat­ing a sep­a­rate pay rate either.

  • http://karlaporter.com/ Karla Porter

    @maureensharib Thanks for start­ing this, the impor­tance can­not be over­stated. You would think between ere and here it would get a lot of atten­tion, instead it’s get­ting apa­thy… what’s wrong with our gen­der? Maybe it’s us? Maybe the fight is over and we lost and some of us can’t accept it?

    @imjustagoyle I hope it wasn’t an expen­sive La Perla or even Victoria’s S. I’m a peace, love and hap­pi­ness girl too. That’s why I love you.

    @Shennee Hillary couldn’t pull it off. She still hasn’t fig­ured out how to man­age pub­lic per­cep­tion. Of course, it’s uncharted ter­ri­tory so I’ll cut her some slack. I’m dis­ap­pointed though. She ticked me off when she stayed with Bill for per­sonal and pro­fes­sional gain to appeal to con­ser­v­a­tive dems.

    • mau­reen­sharib

      @karlaporter You would think — but don’t get dis­cour­aged. This is a tough topic — females who want to speak out don’t for fear of retal­i­a­tion in the work­places of the jobs they need the pay­check from and (most) males don’t because…why? It prof­its them not to! Why give legs to a sub­ject that deserves it if it’s going to take money out of your pocket some­where down the line?

      It’s a catch-22 women are caught in. Most women live hand-to-mouth and are afraid to rock the tiny boats of their secu­rity in a mighty and fear­ful sea.

      Believe me, there are a lot of sis­ters sit­ting on the side­lines thinkin’ “You go, girl!” For those of you read­ing this, and you want to do some­thing, pass the word along in the best way you can — if you’re fear­ful some­one might sab­o­tage your own right to speak out cre­ate an anony­mous Inter­net per­sona and point your read­ers to this sub­ject. The impor­tant thing is that you do some­thing because if you don’t this issue is going to go on and on and on and on and you, your daugh­ters, your grand­daugh­ters, your great grand­daugh­ters and on and on and on will be affected.

      The fight is over only when it leaves us. I don’t think we’ve lost the war — maybe some bat­tles — there is no shame in that if we con­tinue the cam­paign. Churchill said:
      “In war, res­o­lu­tion; in defeat, defi­ance; in vic­tory, magnanimity.”

      What a won­der­ful, mag­nan­i­mous world it would be if women ruled it.

      • http://karlaporter.com/ Karla Porter

        Hey Mau­reen, this is a great con­ver­sa­tion that I hope con­tin­ues to gain steam. Actu­ally I don’t need women to rule the world though, I need them to be respected as co-rulers for the tal­ents they bring to the table as busi­ness part­ners and lead­ers and not treated as cof­fee fetch­ers and errand girls. XXOO Karla

  • shen­nee

    Another Great Post Karla~
    This topic really get’s me “fired up”. Hillary Clin­ton put 18 mil­lion cracks in the glass ceil­ing, but we need to shat­ter it together.
    Let’s keep this con­ver­a­tion going! We need to lead to change, and change to lead…
    Well done

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention We Can Haz Equal Pay | KARLA PORTER | Human Capital & New Media -- Topsy.com

  • imjustagoyle

    I’m burn­ing my bra as we speak, Karla!

    Seri­ously though, my mother was always adamant about the fact that I be savvy enough to rely only on myself. She didn’t want my life to revolve around hav­ing a man because in her life, they hadn’t done jack. She taught me the les­son early that men don’t like it when you say they aren’t play­ing FAIR. She taught me to stand up for myself and not to apol­o­gize for it. If the men don’t like it, point out how UNFAIR they are being and watch the atmos­phere change.

    Well, it’s not 100% true in all sit­u­a­tions but I have found that in most cases, it works. I have never been apolo­getic about being aggres­sive in busi­ness. I’m a peace, love & hap­pi­ness gal but you mess with my money or my future and we’re gonna go rounds.

    Great post, Karla! I think some women need a reminder.

  • mau­reen­sharib

    Yes, Karla, we can! Join in the out­cry. Say some­thing like Karla has here (and over there, on ERE). Don’t be afraid. They might bite but it won’t hurt. Remem­ber, right is might.


ADVERTISEMENT