Skip to content now.

Thoughts on Memorial Day

May 31, 2010 / Just Me / Trackback

If you know me at all you know I am not a morn­ing per­son. But get­ting up really early ( I think 6am on a week­end qual­i­fies) to honor peo­ple who were drafted in older wars and con­flicts and vol­un­teered to put them­selves in harm’s way in more recent years — and lost their life because of it, seems so utterly insignif­i­cant and I feel com­pelled to do it.

I marched and felt truly strange when peo­ple along the parade route mouthed their thank yous and applauded. You see, I thank the mil­i­tary for help­ing to shape who I am. In fact, I’m an advo­cate of com­pul­sory ser­vice. It might sound really rad­i­cal to some but when I think of the ben­e­fits and how other great coun­tries have com­pul­sory ser­vice it just seems to me like a good idea.

I often hear peo­ple say how star­tled they are when they go to Can­cun and see mil­i­tary all over the place. It’s a shock because in the US we’re not used to see­ing armed mil­i­tary doing high­way safety checks and patrolling cities and beaches. They are first respon­ders when there is a nat­ural dis­as­ter like a hur­ri­cane or earth­quake and they are very good at it. I was liv­ing there dur­ing a hur­ri­cane and they quickly had sup­plies to us on Cozumel.

Mex­ico fought with allies in WWII but since has only had inter­nal rebel skir­mishes so they use the mil­i­tary to do pub­lic works projects — kind of like our Army Corp of Engi­neers, air­port secu­rity inspec­tions and pro­vide secu­rity for ports, etc. If you don’t serve you can’t vote and you can’t get a pass­port to leave the coun­try. You’re expected to “give some­thing” to your coun­try in order to get those ben­e­fits. I can’t say I object.

You think this is odd? It’s not odd at all. Many coun­tries have sim­i­lar mil­i­tary con­scrip­tion pro­grams and of course all have vol­un­tary ser­vice. The United King­dom, Aus­tria, Liberia and other coun­tries allow enlist­ment at 16 years old.

I am par­tic­i­pat­ing on a panel this Wednes­day at a col­lege about high school drop out re-engagement. What if we offered drop outs a 2 year enlist­ment that included an inten­sive GED pro­gram and then a tra­di­tional mil­i­tary career school? At 18 they would have earned their GED, learned a career, earned 2 years of salary — not spent time on pub­lic assis­tance, served their coun­try and become inde­pen­dent pro­duc­tive adults.

I think I’m going to pro­pose that.

What do you think?



  • Brenda L
    Karla,

    One more thing - you wear that uniform well, lady!!!
  • Brenda L - thanks =) BTW the experience made me understand what I was made of, to not doubt myself, to trust myself and to know I could depend on myself, be self-sufficient, strong and decisive. Those are attributes I value greatly. They have saved my butt on several occasions.
  • Brenda L
    Karla,

    That is an excellent idea! Our schools are so burdened with drop out prevention classes and other issues, it would make perfect sense for students to have a program they could turn to. So many small towns across the country have no educational alternatives, and students are not encouraged to seek an alternative way of education. It's either traditional public education or drop out and this is not working any more for our youth. Some of the kids just can't learn in traditional classrooms, they need the 'hands on' approach, along with a strong sense of accomplishment and self worth. It would work to turn a whole generation and future generations around in a positive way. I'm all for capping public school age at 16 and requiring either finishing school or military. Maybe our Jr./Sr. high schools should be turned into finishing schools, instead of traditional classes?

    On a side note - Locally, our technical school which trained a lot of electricians, masons, draftsmen, mechanics, plumbers, firemen, etc. closed their doors after 40 years of service......I've seen it as a real mistake. Our 175K population has only two choices - Community college or a very, very expensive private 4 year college. No real option for 'hands on' technical training.

    Finally - it is great to hear you say your military experience shaped who you are! It's refreshing to hear for a change. Does it make you sick to read the news around the country of how many American flags were burned and destroyed on Memorial Day? No respect - and I don't want to hear that it's someone's God given 'right' in this country to desecrate the flag - they should be held accountable!
  • I'm OK with people demonstrating and burning flags. I don't believe it is their God given right, just their good fortune to have been born here or have processed papers..I would much rather that than a country that cut your hand off for stomping on a flag... or worse. however, if I have to pay taxes then so does everyone.
  • Wow, Karla! It is great to hear another veteran advocate for compulsory service. I have been an advocate of compulsory service since early in my military career, and it only increased as I was assigned to other countries that had it. My husband doesn't agree with me on this, but his opinion is colored by serving during the Viet Nam era. He volunteered, but got an up close look at a drafted Army of soldiers often didn't want to be there, but weren't as adept at getting out of it as many who fled to Canada, burned their draft cards, or had the political pull, money, or other means to avoid serving. When I talk about compulsory service, I am talking about it being an obligation for everyone (of course, minus those who are disabled, etc.) The first year of military service is a tremendous time of growth for most young people. Compulsory service would greatly enhance the maturity level of those same young people before they enter college and/or the workforce, as well as giving them a greater appreciation for the freedom we are afforded in this country. There are a number of countries that have been doing it for years that have good models in place - some with obligations as short as one year and as long as 2 1/2 years. Many countries also use military service as a meanst to teach their young adults about life in other parts of their country - by intentionally assigning city boys to the country, mountain dwellers to the oceanfront areas, etc . I think that the capability to pick and choose from the best aspects of different systems could be a great benefit.
  • ndslotnick - I have seen suggestions for something like a national service corp, kind of like a domestic peace corps. I like that idea too. We need people to help with natural disaster relief and development of areas in Appalachia, etc. What I am not fine with is kids learning a system that was put in place with good reason but worked over by people who feel entitled to have others do the work of supporting them or those raised to think it's acceptable or worse - desirable.. Having the freedom to be non-productive at the cost of others is not acceptable. I believe there are better ways than currently in place to engage youth. Maybe not the same way for every child is the answer. Schools are run like assembly lines to pump out people who can recite times tables...
  • Shennee
    Karla-
    You really are an most wonderful authentic person. I am so very blessed to have met you and I consider you a true friend:) I thank you for your past service to our country, and all you do to impact the lives of countless others.
    Happy Memorial Day!
    Shennee
  • Shennee - I highly doubt the blessings part is true but the authentic part is for sure. I hope your weekend was fantastic too!
  • Karla,

    I served as both a reservist and active duty enlisted person in the Army and I think what makes our Armed Forces so great is that it's made up of an all volunteer force. So the ones that serve are the ones who made the decisions to serve and decide in which skill set they serve in. So as far as compulsory service I'm not a fan. However, I do think an initiative focused on drop outs entering into a program such as the one you described could help some the rate of success for drop outs get better. I would venture to say that most (I'm careful not to say all) of the drop outs do so because of a lack of direction or proper guidance and structure. The military would be a great way to instill some of these characteristics into the young drop out

  • Rinish - Our military is no doubt GREAT but really our generation is the first to see it all volunteer. So many drafted soldiers did amazing things from Washington's Army through the Vietnam War, it must be a testament to their patriotism and understanding that failure was not an option in order to preserve what we have, our way of life and borders. Above and beyond the benefit of a more educated nation the benefits of going through boot camp could help stem our obesity epidemic, train the majority of our population in basic first aid and defense - not to mention how to iron a shirt for a job interview. I hear what you're saying about the word "compulsory" and I think offering incentives too attractive to turn down (like tuition forgiveness, tax incentives, etc) could work to engage people without having to go that route. I'm starting to like it more and more... if it ever gets to Congress I'll count on your support =) P.S. I would only be in favor of volunteers being deployed.
blog comments powered by Disqus