Skip to content now.

The Greatest Internship on Earth

Oct 24, 2009 / Workforce / Trackback

diplomaIn 2010 I have one con­crete albeit ambi­tious goal, to cre­ate the great­est col­lege intern­ship pro­gram on earth. The non­profit cham­ber and eco­nomic devel­op­ment orga­ni­za­tion I work for approved it and it’s offi­cially in my work plan as my num­ber one objec­tive for the com­ing year. The prospect of help­ing emerg­ing tal­ent meet oppor­tu­nity is very moti­vat­ing and exciting.

There are many flaws in the way cur­rent intern­ship pro­grams work.

There are sev­eral national intern­ship web­sites that act as infor­ma­tion por­tals and “job boards”. Many employ­ers are not famil­iar with these web­sites and when career ser­vices offices tell them they need to cre­ate employer accounts and jump through hoops they quickly get frus­trated and don’t fol­low through.  Because these web­sites are national, com­pa­nies don’t nec­es­sar­ily attract local stu­dents. At the same time, most stu­dents man­age classes and intern­ships dur­ing the same semes­ter so they need to stay local. It’s impor­tant to man­age intern­ship pro­grams locally to allow for super­vi­sion of and assis­tance with the intern and employer expe­ri­ence. Intro­duc­ing stu­dents to oppor­tu­ni­ties with local employ­ers also helps aid in the reten­tion of regional tal­ent and pre­ven­tion of “brain drain”.

Stu­dents and employ­ers scram­ble to find each other. Employ­ers will­ing to pro­vide an oppor­tu­nity to a stu­dent shouldn’t have to work hard to find one or have to reach out to mul­ti­ple col­lege career ser­vices offices to adver­tise. Student’s should under­stand employer expec­ta­tions and how to con­duct an intern­ship or job search.

Another chal­lenge is the con­cept many employ­ers have of what an intern­ship is. While there are com­pa­nies that look to recruit entry level col­lege grads and rec­og­nize that “try before you buy” is an excel­lent way to do it while assist­ing in the student’s edu­ca­tion, many times what com­pa­nies are look­ing for is cheap labor. Errand boys, enve­lope stuffers and fil­ing clerks do not require col­lege edu­ca­tions and intern­ships shouldn’t be framed around these functions.

The goal is to enlist com­pa­nies with a mis­sion of com­mu­nity part­ner­ship and good cor­po­rate cit­i­zen­ship as exten­sions of higher edu­ca­tion. That means that through this pro­gram they’ll pledge to do their part and take on a cer­tain num­ber of interns per year under spe­cially crafted intern work plans based on job descrip­tions and goals that will be approved and pro­vide mean­ing­ful expe­ri­en­tial learn­ing for students.

Stu­dents won’t just walk into an intern­ship either. They’ll apply, inter­view and go through a selec­tion process just like if it were a reg­u­lar posi­tion they were going after.To help them pre­pare, they’ll attend pro­gram admin­is­tered career prepa­ra­tion work­shops to assist them with resumes and inter­view skills. They’ll learn the dif­fer­ence between non-exempt and exempt employ­ees, go through mock ori­en­ta­tion and non-harassment train­ing and review and dis­cuss exam­ple employee poli­cies and handbooks.

Employ­ers will pro­vide an ori­en­ta­tion, an intern men­tor and reg­u­lar coach­ing and feed­back that is doc­u­mented. Mid and end of semes­ter for­mal per­for­mance eval­u­a­tions will be con­ducted and delivered.

Stu­dents need to have tools and expe­ri­ence to set them up for career suc­cess. The pro­gram will pro­vide a one semes­ter real world career expe­ri­ence and the tools to be suc­cess­ful. Employ­ers will have a more pro­duc­tive and func­tion­ing junior careerist on board, the oppor­tu­nity to expe­ri­ence a poten­tial addi­tion to their team and a huge hand in the devel­op­ment of com­mu­nity tal­ent in exchange for their com­mit­ment to act as “career labs”.

The logis­tics of the pro­gram require cen­tral­iza­tion to a regional com­mon career ser­vices cen­ter shared by all area insti­tu­tions of higher edu­ca­tion and employ­ers. This means stu­dents from all par­tic­i­pat­ing col­leges will seek their intern­ships from one source. They won’t have to be con­cerned that not all com­pa­nies will­ing to pro­vide intern­ship oppor­tu­ni­ties haven’t reached out to recruit at their par­tic­u­lar school. Con­versely, employ­ers will no longer have to reach out to many career ser­vices offices to announce intern­ship oppor­tu­ni­ties. They’ll also have one con­tact, one source, to man­age their tal­ent search. Col­lege career ser­vices offices will serve as on cam­pus liaisons for the pro­gram and have more time to focus on work­ing with stu­dents to iden­tify their career goals and pro­vide resume prepa­ra­tion and inter­view skills assistance.

As a non­profit orga­ni­za­tion at the helm, we’ll be happy to share our model with other like minded orga­ni­za­tions every­where who want to improve the ways tal­ent meets oppor­tu­nity. I’m ask­ing you to reflect and com­ment here on the pos­i­tive and neg­a­tive aspects of your col­lege intern­ship and also about intern­ships at the com­pany you work for.  If you have great ideas about what would work bet­ter or what not to do I want to hear them. Your com­ments will help to cre­ate the great­est intern­ship pro­gram on earth!



  • Shennee - Thanks for your encouragement and support!

    GL - I would hope that by a college student's senior year they have strongly formed ideas about the careers they aspire to. After all, most receive credits. But I do agree, trying on a job is important for many and I'm a good example of someone who wandered around without real direction for many years until I stumbled upon what I do and enjoy. I will keep thinking.

    HRMargo - One of the true virtues of social networking is the vast scope of SME's and diverse group of professionals so readily willing to step up to discuss and offer encouragement and assistance - like many of my readers that have become my friends.

    Audrey - It's got to be the worst to be all excited thinking you're going to get real world experience and work side-by-side with a pro only to be stuck in the archive room or in front of a shredder. Ensuring there is a meaningful job description and work plan for the intern truly is fundamental. Thanks for the City As School tip. Though they are only in the Boroughs there's nothing wrong with learning from best practices, right?

    Jenny - It's so cool you're reading all the way from Seattle. I have never been there but would love to visit. One of the best things about the Internet is that it can transport you around the world.... I love that you told me you'll be back :-)

    Richard - Your feedback is SO valuable. I am very happy for you that you have a meaning experiential internship. If I were a student and the experience wasn't living up to my expectations I would tell my counselor, career services office or whoever the the right person would be. But, I know a lot of students would not feel comfortable doing that so they end up disappointed.
  • Hello Karla, as a current intern, who has done multiple internships, I can be sincere on the fact that internships can be either a valued learning experience, giving you a head start on the working world, or just a big waste of time. If you are at an internship like the one I’m at now, then you are probably given hands on work to be done, as well as playing a role in supporting your company while learning about the type of work the company handles. An internship like this is a great learning opportunity, however not all are like this. There is a vast amount of internships where this is no learning to be done, and the tasks typically consist of running errands, filling/database entry, and paper shredding etc. This is reason enough why I support your idea for a centralized internship organization, because than interns and employers can come together to find exactly what they are looking for, as well as having the ability to filter out tedious internships.
  • In my last year in high school, I went all over New York City as a intern for credit toward graduation. You might want to contact City As School, I believe they might be in more than one city by now. I went to great places, however, some places had nothing for me to do and I was left to invent my own projects.
    I think companies should plan in advance the work they will give to interns and think about what they will teach them in return for their work.
    Good Luck to you in your project and let me know if I can help in any way.
  • hrmargo
    If anyone can do this Karla, I know you can and there's an entire twitterverse behind you!
  • Karla...good post and an awesome goal. There are lots of areas of improvement in current internship thinking---on both sides of the table. An area often overlooked is that is OK for someone to take an internship even if the only reason is to rule out that sort of job. Life is about having as many experiences as you can before you turn 40, er, 60. Whatever.
    JT Odonnell of JT and Dale and careerealism makes great use of interns in the careers space.
    Keep up the thought provoking writing...

    GL Hoffman
  • Neil
    Hello Karla....just started interning with Audrey at HCR, where she told me about your internship plan. I must say it's great idea with a lot of structure and organization. I've personally had a couple internships in college, where I've had differing experiences. My first internship was rahter bland, doing clerical work and not actually learning about my job. As for my most recent one, I felt more compelled to contribute to the company because I have given hands on-field related work that can be applied to a career. I feel that the core of an internship is to learn about a potential career and gain experience, which can't be done filing papers or getting coffee. I feel that your program appears to be more of a co-op given the amount of time, focus, and energy devoted to the plan, but none-the-less would be beneficial in terms of preparing a student for the future.
  • Neil, thank you so much for your comments. I'm so glad you had a better experience with your 2nd internship, I have seen how frustrating it can be when its not a good match or there is no work plan. Your perspective is important to me. If you know of other interns that might be interested in providing theirs please feel free to send them the link to this.

    Hugs to Audrey for letting you know about this.
  • Shennee Rutt
    Great Idea! I personally did not have an opportunity to Intern in College, but, I have Facilitated an High School Internship during my tenure at an Retirement community as Employment Representative (HR REP). I was in charge of the entire program from start to finish!
    Such a rewarding career experience,
    Let me know If I can assist you in anyway.
    Shennee
blog comments powered by Disqus