Skip to content now.

Why Don’t I get a Call Back?

Feb 01, 2010 / Job Seeker / Trackback

Here’s a Monday morning shout out to job seekers and a list to help you understand some common reasons why your phone might not be ringing. It’s not an exhaustive list, just one to get you thinking. You want me to think of everything?

No response after submitting a resume or application:

  • You are applying to jobs you’re not qualified for.
  • Your resume or application has grammar errors that turned the recruiter off.
  • You did not complete the application appropriately or shoved a resume in it and wrote “see resume” on it.
  • Your resume was not targeted to the position you are applying for (you sent the same resume to apply for different types of jobs).
  • It looks like a “to do” list and there’s no story –> You look like a robot.
  • You have a shoddy job history with a couple of months here and there and employers are not willing to take a risk to train you and have you leave.

If you get calls and then do not get invited to interviews it could be because:

  • You did not sound interested during the phone screen, were monotone and totally lacked enthusiasm.
  • You had poor speaking skills or lack of correct grammar.
  • You didn’t have much to say and the dead air was agonizing and the recruiter couldn’t bear the though of having to do it all over again in person.
  • You said “I don’t know” a lot.
  • You were pompous and or cocky or had some other poor attitude on the phone.
  • You were negative about your past employers or about anything else.
  • The Recruiter wanted to talk about your experience and skills and you wanted to talk about the money.
  • It was 11:00am and your mom answered the phone and had to call you out of bed to take the call (I am not kidding).

You landed an interview but didn’t get a job offer or invitation to a second interview:

  • You were late or rushing in the door just on time.
  • You were dressed inappropriately and did not convey a professional image (either too casual, sloppy, wrinkled, thought you were going to a nightclub, etc).
  • You lacked grooming and/or hygiene.
  • You couldn’t maintain eye contact.
  • You had no questions that showed true interest.
  • You acted disinterested or distracted.
  • You were not polite and/or courteous or lacked in some other social skill.
  • You had weak answers (or none at all).
  • You rambled on painfully when asked a question.
  • You couldn’t stick to the topic of the question, lacked focus and when asked about “A” you ended up talking about “Z”.
  • You acted inappropriately or weird.
  • You performed poorly on the assessment testing.
  • You conned the person who did the phone interview about your skills but couldn’t do it in person.
  • You lied on your application or resume and the background check picked it up.

Now, go through the reasons I listed again and see if you can find an area in which you can improve upon. Self assessment isn’t easy but it is critical to your success.

Feel free to chime in and list other things that can be job search stoppers…




Responses

shennee
Feb 01, 2010 at 1:04 PM

Thanks Karla for a very timely post. I read your list TWICE.
I am sure there are areas for each of us to “improve”. I actually had the Mom answer the phone, and to get the employee out of bed happen to me in an agency setting. Total failure there. Not impressed.
Appreciate you being passionate about helping Jobseekers everywhere!
Shennee


claudinerenee
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:10 PM

Awesome article (except YOUR typo).


August Cohen
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:33 PM

Karla,

This is a must-see list for any job seeker, and friends and family who love those job seekers. Unfortunately, the perpetrators of many of the above actions aren't self-aware enough to recognize them. A firm nudging often is needed, and you provided that in an easy to understand list. It will be bookmarked for future reference; I know I will need it sooner rather than later.


Karla Porter
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:45 PM

@claudinerenee – You are my heroine this morning for making me a better person.

People, learn from me! I would never suggest writing a resume at 5:30a.m. while trying to feed the dog and cats, shower, get ready for work, etc.. If you must, then at least get @claudinerenee to proof read it for you – she nails it!


Charlie Judy
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:48 PM

I would add to “No response after submitting a resume or application” that the Employer's ATS is ineffective and your resume was never even looked at or the Employer's recruiter is worthless and didn't take the time to truly screen best candidates…


Karla Porter
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:48 PM

@shennee – The good thing about mom being there to get the dude out of bed is that she'll be there to get him out of bed to get his butt to work too.


Karla Porter
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:51 PM

@August Perhaps job seekers would consider printing this list and taping it to all the mirrors in the house. You are a Special Agent, you have this list memorized, who are you trying to kid? Or, is there some type of subliminal message in your comment?


Karla Porter
Feb 01, 2010 at 4:58 PM

@Charlie – Oh Charlie, there you go getting all technical. Are you for or against the No Child Left Behind propaganda? In all seriousness, this is one of the prime reasons candidates should keep a record (good old Excel Spreadsheet will do) of where and to whom they submitted their resumes. I wouldn't trust just uploading it to an ATS… I would use my job seeker super powers to find out who the Recruiter or Hiring Manager is and also send it to them by email. Then I would wait a few days and make a follow up call. What do you think? BTW – Thanks for stopping by!


claudinerenee
Feb 01, 2010 at 5:05 PM

You, my dear, are hilarious. My mother always said I should have been an editor but I pictured myself reading ridiculously boring research articles that explain high-tech engineering problems or, worse yet, adult fiction books about, well, let's just say “with erotic content”.


August Cohen
Feb 01, 2010 at 5:12 PM

Well, you caught me Karla. My Special Agent super powers aren't up to your level yet:-). I am bookmarking it for my clients benefit, not particulary mine. I know they will listen to you – as you are such a respected authority – and the fact you know how to use a weapon doesn't hurt either. They will certainly
think twice before misbehaving. The mission continues…..


shennee
Feb 01, 2010 at 8:12 PM

Karla- Yes and no about the Dude who's Mom had to wake him up. He did not make a good impression out the gate. If he is old enough to still be living home with Mom and Dad, He should be responsible enough to answer the phone about a job, and SHOW up to work.
Sigh,,,,,,,,,


Most Tweeted Articles by Recruitment Experts: MrTweet
Feb 02, 2010 at 5:34 AM

Your article was most tweeted by Recruitment experts in the Twitterverse…

Come see other top popular articles surfaced by Recruitment experts!…


Tweets that mention Why Don’t I get a Call Back? | KARLA PORTER | Human Capital & New Media -- Topsy.com
Feb 04, 2010 at 12:19 PM

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Heather R. Huhman, Jennifer McClure, Karla Porter, August Cohen, Maureen McCann and others. Maureen McCann said: Tough love. Excellent info for #jobseekers! RT @karla_porter: Job seekers, ask yourself "Why don't I get a call back?" http://is.gd/7to5C [...]


Joni Liebel
Feb 08, 2010 at 1:32 PM

Carla these are great! Of course we all try to stay positive, and support people in our lives who are searching for jobs. But when things aren't “happening” as planned or expected, it's these hard questions that shake things up, and can result in some new insights. Brilliant!
Joni
http://www.joniliebel.com


Karla Porter
Feb 09, 2010 at 7:58 PM

@Joni – Thanks for your visit and kind words. Shennee Rutt, another reader, told me I am “tough love” – it's funny I just see it as practical =)


Brenda
Mar 09, 2010 at 8:30 PM

Karla, Can't believe I didn't see this before. This is worth reposting!

Brenda


Penny for your thoughts







ADVERTISEMENT